Question 1

What makes ItalianWine.Store different from other online wine shops?

Accepted Answer

Through proprietary research criteria, we source a specific caliber of wines from Italy. We work directly with small families who produce what we call human-scale wines — people who live in their vineyards and who make wine in the hundreds or low thousands of bottles, not hundreds of thousands. Certainly not millions. No middlemen, no pay-to-play selection. Every bottle here was chosen because of a match in criteria and a real relationship with the people who made it. And we usually uncover them before the media and more commercial importers do.

Question 2

Where do the wines on ItalianWine.Store come from?

Accepted Answer

Our producers span Italy from north to south — the Fumane Valley in Veneto, the Madonie Mountains of Sicily, the Apennines of Molise, Sardinia, and Tuscany. Each region is represented by one or two artisan families, not a portfolio of commercial labels.

Question 3

What Italian wine should I buy if I'm just getting started?

Accepted Answer

Start with something from Southern Italy — a Nero d'Avola from Sicily or a Montepulciano from Molise. These wines are approachable, food-friendly, and typically under $30. They'll give you a real sense of what Italian wine tastes like without the intimidation factor.

Question 4

What's the best Italian wine under $25?

Accepted Answer

For white wine, Castellucci Miano Miano Bianco Catarratto at $22-$23 is one of the most interesting bottles we carry at that price. It's made from a rare native grape that grows almost nowhere else in the world but Sicily. You're getting something genuinely unique, not a mass-market label. For reds, Battaglio Nebbiolo Langhe — one of Italy's most treasured red grapes — at under $25 will feel like a transformation for the value and experience you get.

Question 5

What Italian wine should I bring to a dinner party?

Accepted Answer

A Chianti or a Valpolicella Superiore. They're crowd-pleasing, food-flexible, and most guests haven't tasted the small-batch versions of these wines. Our Cantina Tuscania Chianti at $25 consistently impresses people who think they already know Chianti.

Question 6

What is artisan Italian wine?

Accepted Answer

Artisan wine is made in small quantities — most of our producers make under 5,000 bottles. A family that farms, harvests, and bottles everything themselves. The opposite of industrial wine, which is blended at scale from machine-harvested grapes and designed to taste consistent year after year. Artisan wine tastes like a place and a season. Industrial wine tastes like a brand.

Question 7

Are there Italian wines I can actually age at home?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Amarone, Brunello di Montalcino, Barolo, and Barbaresco are the well-known ones — 10 to 20-year wines. But we also carry lesser-known age-worthy bottles like Taurasi, Sagrantino di Montefalco, and Aglianico del Vulture. These age just as well and cost significantly less.

Question 8

What food pairs well with Italian red wine?

Accepted Answer

Italian reds were made to go with food — it's in their DNA. A general rule: the bolder the sauce, the bolder the wine. Chianti with tomato-based pasta. Valpolicella with roasted meats. Amarone with braised short rib or aged cheese. Lighter reds like Battaglio Dolcetto or Castellucci Miano Perricone work beautifully with pizza.

Question 9

What is Tintilia and why haven't I heard of it?

Accepted Answer

Tintilia is a native red grape from Molise, a small region in southern Italy that most people couldn't find on a map. It nearly went extinct. A handful of artisan producers, including TerreSacre, brought it back. It's earthy, structured, and completely unlike anything else in Italy. You haven't heard of it because only a dozen or so families make it.

Question 10

What Italian wine region should I explore next if I already love Tuscany?

Accepted Answer

It depends. If you're into Chianti, go south to Campania. It's home to Taurasi — made from the Aglianico grape — which produces wines with the same seriousness and aging potential as Barolo, but with a darker, more volcanic character. It's one of Italy's greatest under-the-radar regions. If you're more into Super Tuscans, go to Sardinia and try their Cannonau and Cagnulari. Big reds with fruit, spice, and power. They'll also get you hooked on Vermentino, their white wine.

Question 11

Is Italian wine natural or organic?

Accepted Answer

Many small Italian producers farm organically or biodynamically without seeking certification, because certification is expensive and time-consuming. Our Cantina Tuscania and Ugolini wines are certified organic in Italy, though not in the U.S. We also carry natural winemakers like Terre Antiche, Francesco Fiori, and Cascina del Monastero, who practice spontaneous fermentation with the native yeast of the grape for a more homeopathic and traditional style. For the others, we know the farming practices personally because we visit the estates. We wouldn't carry a wine we didn't trust at the source. Our families actually drink their own wines — they're not corporate executives pushing a brand while choosing something else for themselves.

Question 12

What's the difference between Valpolicella and Amarone?

Accepted Answer

Both come from the same grapes in Verona's Valpolicella zone. Valpolicella is made from fresh grapes — it's lighter, earlier-drinking, and more affordable. Amarone is made from grapes that are dried for months before fermentation, which concentrates the sugars and flavor. The result is a rich, powerful wine that can age for decades. Think of Amarone as Valpolicella's more intense, age-worthy sibling.

Question 13

How do I know which vintage to buy?

Accepted Answer

For everyday drinking, vintage matters less than producer. For age-worthy wines, look for 2015, 2016, and 2019 — exceptional years across most of Italy. We note the vintage on every product page and only carry bottles we've personally evaluated. Vintages that are less than 5-stars are actually valuable to us, because that's where you see who the great winemakers really are. Almost anyone can make great wine when the conditions are favorable. But a true artisan will make good wine in a difficult year — just less of it, to protect the quality. That discipline is what we look for.

Question 14

Can I buy Italian wine online and ship to my state?

Accepted Answer

Yes. ItalianWine.Store ships to most U.S. states. Check the checkout process for your specific state's availability. Wine shipping laws vary by state, but we handle compliance on our end.

Question 15

What is a hidden gem Italian wine?

Accepted Answer

A wine from a region or grape variety that most Americans have never encountered — made in under 50,000 bottles annually, but delivering exceptional quality at a fraction of the price of famous and familiar labels. Tintilia from Molise. Iolei Cannonau from Sardinia. Battaglio from Piedmont. Wines that don't have marketing budgets but have everything else.

Question 16

What is Breathenology?

Accepted Answer

Breathenology is a wine philosophy coined by Tony Margiotta, based on the belief that wine is a living, breathing thing with seven dimensions of experience — from its origin and craft to its cultural resonance. The goal is to move beyond tasting notes and reach wine's deepest state: resonance. It's the foundation of everything we do at ItalianWine.Store and the Breathing Wine club.

Question 17

How are your producers selected?

Accepted Answer

Every producer on this site was visited in person, tasted extensively in comparison with peers in each typology, and chosen based on style, quality, farming integrity, winemaking philosophy, and the story of the family behind the wine. We don't take commissions from producers. We don't list wines because someone asked us to. The selection reflects our wine values.

Question 18

What is the Breathing Wine club?

Accepted Answer

Breathing Wine is our monthly wine club built around discovery and wine philosophy. Each month, members receive a curated selection of artisan Italian wines along with a secret codex that transforms your experience — the region, the family, the story — so you're not just drinking wine, you're learning it. It's designed for people who want to build a real relationship with Italian wine over time. Each codex reveals a dimension of Breathenology which deepens that relationship.

Question 19

Who is Tony Margiotta?

Accepted Answer

Tony Margiotta is the founder of ItalianWine.Store and Gladiator Wine Distribution, an importer of artisan Italian wines. He's the award-winning author of Hidden Gems of Italy, The Wine List That Sells Itself, and Wine in Your 20s, and grew up in an Italian immigrant household with family roots in Molise. His approach to wine is personal, not academic — built on the pillars of origin, craft, and culture. He writes and speaks about Italian wine as a cultural experience, not a competition.

Question 20

Why should I buy from ItalianWine.Store instead of a large wine retailer?

Accepted Answer

Large retailers carry what sells. We carry what's worth drinking. Every wine here comes from a producer we know personally, from a region we've visited, made in quantities that most retailers never see. If you want wine that tastes like local Italy rather than wine that tastes like a soft drink, this is where to shop.

Question 21

What's the difference between importing wine and just reselling it?

Accepted Answer

Most online wine shops buy from a domestic distributor who bought from an importer who bought from a broker in Italy. We are the importer. Gladiator Wine Distribution brings these wines directly from the families to the U.S. From the moment we pick up the wine at the winery in Italy, it travels in temperature-controlled containers — through pickup, ocean transport, and all the way to our warehouse in New Jersey, where it rests at a constant 60 degrees Fahrenheit around the clock. Heat is wine's worst enemy. Most people don't know that a single warm cargo hold can age a wine years in a matter of weeks. We obsess over this because the families we work with obsess over making it. The least we can do is deliver it to you the way it left them.

Question 22

How is ItalianWine.Store different from wine subscription boxes?

Accepted Answer

Most wine clubs send whatever the importer is pushing that month. Breathing Wine is built around a philosophy — each selection is paired with a codex that teaches you something specific about wine's deeper dimensions. You're not just receiving bottles. You're building fluency.

Item added to your cart

Shipping & Returns